The Quick Answer (So You Can Act Now)
- Pain at the thumb-side wrist (radial styloid) that zings with lifting a baby, opening jars, or making a fist and bending the wrist toward the little finger = most likely de Quervain’s tendinopathy—irritation of the abductor pollicis longus (APL) and extensor pollicis brevis (EPB) tendons in the first dorsal compartment. Early wins: forearm-based thumb-spica bracing, short phase of relative rest, topical NSAID, and progressive tendon-loading exercises.[1–6]
- Pain at the base of the thumb (at the “saddle” joint) with pinch or twist, a squarish or bumpy joint, morning stiffness that eases with movement = more likely thumb CMC (basal-joint) osteoarthritis. Early wins: short opponens/CMC brace that supports the base (but lets the wrist move), heat before activity, isometric thenar and first dorsal interosseous strengthening, and pinch-reducing ergonomics.[7–12]
- Red flags: numbness/tingling into the thumb (possible median nerve compression), red/hot swollen joint with fever (infection), high-energy trauma, visible deformity, or night pain unrelieved by rest → seek medical care.[13–15]
Why phones aggravate thumbs (and what’s different about each diagnosis)
Scrolling + one-handed texting combine three stressors: prolonged thumb abduction, repetitive tendon gliding under a tight pulley at the wrist, and sustained pinch load at the CMC joint. De Quervain’s is a tendon-sheath irritation; CMC arthritis is cartilage and ligament laxity/degeneration. Both hurt with phones—but where and which motions provoke pain point you to the right fix.[1–3,7–9]
Pattern check: where exactly is your pain?
Signs that favor de Quervain’s
- Pinpoint tenderness over the radial styloid (thumb-side wrist) rather than the thumb base
- Pain when gripping, lifting a child, pouring a kettle, or ulnar-deviating the wrist with the thumb tucked
- Clicking or creaking over the tendons; sometimes mild swelling in the first dorsal compartment
- Often postpartum or after a sudden jump in repetitive thumb use (new phone, gaming, photo editing)[1–6]
Signs that favor thumb CMC arthritis
- Ache or burning at the base of the thumb (just distal to the wrist crease), worse with pinch (turning keys, jar lids, zippering)
- Visible squaring or bump at the base, crepitus with grind
- Morning stiffness that loosens with movement; pain with sustained pinch rather than quick tendon motions
- More common after age 45 and in those with ligamentous laxity[7–12]
You can have both. Treat the tendon and the joint slightly differently—especially the brace style and the way you load exercises.
Quick at-home checks (safe to try)
1) Finkelstein-style provocation (for de Quervain’s)
Make a gentle fist with the thumb inside (do not crank hard). Slowly bend the wrist toward the little finger. Sharp pain over the thumb-side wrist supports de Quervain’s. (Clinicians distinguish Finkelstein vs Eichhoff; at home, be gentle to avoid over-provoking.)[2–4]
2) WHAT test (Wrist Hyperflexion and Abduction of the Thumb)
Hold the wrist in gentle flexion; actively lift the thumb up and away. Pain over the first dorsal compartment = de Quervain’s.[3–4]
3) CMC grind (for basal-joint arthritis)
Gently press the thumb metacarpal into the trapezium (toward the wrist) and rotate a little. Deep base-of-thumb pain or crunch points to CMC arthritis. Stop if sharp pain.[8–10]
If any test produces severe pain or numbness, stop and seek evaluation.
Do’s and don’ts (the essentials)
De Quervain’s tendinopathy—Do
- Do wear a forearm-based thumb-spica brace (includes the wrist and immobilizes the thumb CMC and MCP) during painful activities for 2–3 weeks.
- Do use topical NSAID gel over the sore area up to 3–4 times/day as labeled if safe for you.
- Do start pain-free isometrics, then eccentric and slow concentric loading of APL/EPB as symptoms settle.
- Do take micro-breaks during phone use; hold the phone with both hands or use a loop/PopSocket.[1–6,11–12]
De Quervain’s—Don’t
- Don’t keep the brace on 24/7 for weeks—stiffness follows. Use for provoking tasks and outside time, remove for gentle exercises.
- Don’t power through sharp tendon pain with repetitive lifting or pronation-supination drills.
Thumb CMC arthritis—Do
- Do wear a short opponens/CMC brace (supports the base of the thumb, leaves the wrist free) during heavier tasks.
- Do use moist heat before activity and topical NSAID after if sore.
- Do train isometric pinch and first dorsal interosseous/thenar strength; lift with a claw grip (use the whole hand), not tip pinch.
- Do use jar openers, key turners, and thicker pen grips to reduce pinch load.[7–12]
CMC arthritis—Don’t
- Don’t hang heavy grocery bags from the thumb and index.
- Don’t sustain forceful pinch (clothespins, metal clips) without breaks or brace support.
Phone and device ergonomics that actually help
- Two-hand the phone; type with both thumbs or switch to index-finger taps.
- Add a loop/PopSocket so the phone rests on the fingers, not on a wide abducted thumb.
- Rotate tasks: 20–30 minutes scrolling → 1–2 minutes off-device or use voice dictation.
- Tablets: use a stand; keep wrists in neutral, thumbs closer to mid-line rather than splayed.
- Laptop + phone work: reply from the laptop where possible to reduce thumb typing.[11–12]
Evidence-based treatments (what works, and when)
De Quervain’s tendinopathy
- Relative rest + thumb-spica bracing + topical NSAID are first-line. Many improve in 2–6 weeks.[1–6]
- Corticosteroid injection into the first dorsal compartment is highly effective, especially within the first few months; success rates are best when both APL and EPB subcompartments are addressed if a septum is present. A second injection can be considered if the first only partially helps.[2–5]
- Therapeutic exercise: progress from isometrics to eccentric-biased loading for APL/EPB, adding forearm and scapular control.[3–6,11]
- Surgery: release of the first dorsal compartment is reserved for refractory cases after solid conservative care or recurrent symptoms; outcomes are generally good when performed by a hand surgeon.[2–5]
Thumb CMC (basal-joint) arthritis
- Education + brace + activity modification + topical NSAID form the core bundle. Many get sustainable relief without injections or surgery.[7–10,12]
- Hand therapy: isometric pinch, first dorsal interosseous, opponens pollicis, eccentric thenar work; joint protection training and task substitutions.[9–12]
- Injections: intra-articular corticosteroid can calm pain flares for weeks to months; benefit tends to be temporary. Evidence for hyaluronic acid is mixed.[8–10]
- Surgery (for advanced, function-limiting disease): options include trapeziectomy with ligament reconstruction and tendon interposition (LRTI) or suspensionplasty; arthrodesis is reserved for select younger heavy-duty workers. Decision hinges on pain, function, and imaging, after exhausting conservative measures.[8–10]
The right brace for the right problem
- De Quervain’s → forearm-based thumb-spica that includes the wrist (limits tendon gliding under the pulley).
- CMC arthritis → short opponens/CMC brace (stabilizes the base of the thumb, allows wrist motion) so you can still type and carry light items.
Wearing the wrong brace frustrates rehab: a CMC-only brace won’t calm an angry tendon; a long spica can over-immobilize a stable basal joint.[1–3,7–9]
A practical two-week plan
Days 1–3: Calm and classify
- Pick the most likely diagnosis based on pattern and tests.
- De Quervain’s path: brace (forearm-based) during provoking tasks; topical NSAID 3–4×/day; ice 10 minutes after heavier use.
- CMC path: short opponens brace for chores; heat before tasks, topical NSAID after; swap pinch for claw grip and tools.
- Phone rules: two-hand hold, loop/stand, voice dictation for long replies.
Days 4–7: Start loading smart
- De Quervain’s:
- Isometric thumb abduction and extension (pain-free effort): 5–7-second holds × 8–10, 2–3×/day.
- Add eccentric thumb abduction with a light band (assist up, slow 3–4 s down) × 8–12.
- CMC arthritis:
- Isometric tripod pinch (index + thumb on a folded towel): gentle 5–7-second holds × 10.
- First dorsal interosseous squeezes (rubber ring or towel) × 10–12; opponens slides (thumb to little-finger base) × 10.
- Keep pain during/after $\leq$3/10. If sharper, reduce load.
- De Quervain’s:
Days 8–14: Build capacity
- De Quervain’s: progress to slow concentric–eccentric abduction/extension with band; begin forearm (wrist extensor/flexor) endurance 2–3×/week; reduce brace time.
- CMC arthritis: build endurance holds for pinch (10–12 s), add light functional tasks (e.g., opening containers with adaptive tools), wean brace during easy tasks but keep for heavier chores.
- Reassess phone ergonomics; schedule app-free blocks.
If not improving by day 14, or if function is limited, book a hand specialist. Early injection (de Quervain’s) or custom splinting/therapy (CMC) often restores momentum.[2–5,8–10]
FAQs
Can I still lift weights?
Yes—modify grips. Use neutral-wrist handles, avoid wide-thumb abduction, and keep loads below pain threshold. For de Quervain’s, pause heavy shrugs and farmer’s carries temporarily; for CMC arthritis, avoid crushing pinch and use straps or gloves for grip-heavy lifts.[11–12]
Do kinesiology tape or rigid tape help?
They can provide short-term symptom relief and proprioceptive cueing, especially for CMC support or tendon unloading, but they are adjuncts—pair with exercise and task modification.[9–12]
Topical vs oral anti-inflammatories?
For localized hand pain, topical NSAIDs often deliver good relief with fewer systemic effects; confirm safety with your clinician.[14–15]
How long until I feel better?
De Quervain’s often improves within 2–6 weeks with bracing, loading, and task changes; CMC arthritis is long-term management, but pain and grip can improve substantially in 4–8 weeks with the brace + exercise bundle.[2–6,8–10]
When to seek medical care now
- Numbness/tingling in the thumb, index, or middle finger (possible median nerve compression)
- Hot, red, rapidly swollen joint or fever
- After a fall with significant swelling/bruising (possible fracture)
- Persistent pain despite 2–4 weeks of good conservative care
- Night pain or pain that wakes you from sleep regularly[13–15]
The Bottom Line
- Thumb-side wrist pain that flares with ulnar deviation and gripping is usually de Quervain’s—treat with the long spica, topical anti-inflammatories, and graded tendon loading.
- Base-of-thumb pain with pinch is usually CMC arthritis—use a short opponens brace, joint-protection strategies, heat, and targeted strength.
- Fix your phone ergonomics and training loads; add injections or surgery only when needed. Most people return to painless scrolling, typing, lifting, and daily tasks with the right plan.[1–12]
- Wolf JM, et al. De Quervain’s tenosynovitis: pathophysiology and management. J Hand Surg.
- Richie CA, Briner WW. Corticosteroid injection and splinting for de Quervain’s: outcomes and technique. Clin J Sport Med.
- Ilyas AM. Nonsurgical treatment for de Quervain’s: evidence for splinting, therapy, and injections. Hand Clin.
- Hadianfard MJ, et al. WHAT and Finkelstein tests—diagnostic utility in de Quervain’s. Muscles Ligaments Tendons J.
- Peters-Veluthamaningal C, et al. Corticosteroid injection for de Quervain’s: randomized and observational evidence. Br J Gen Pract / J Hand Surg.
- Avci S, et al. First dorsal compartment anatomy—septa and impact on injection/surgery outcomes. Clin Anat.
- Becker SJ, et al. Thumb CMC osteoarthritis: epidemiology and nonoperative care. J Hand Surg.
- Stahl S, et al. Splinting and corticosteroid injections for thumb basal joint arthritis: systematic review. Arch Phys Med Rehabil.
- Poole JU, Pellegrini VD. Arthritis of the thumb CMC joint: conservative management and joint protection. J Hand Ther.
- Wong MWN, et al. Injections and outcomes in basal joint arthritis. J Orthop Surg.
- Kroon FPB, et al. Exercise therapy and hand function in thumb disorders: evidence overview. Semin Arthritis Rheum.
- American Society of Hand Therapists. Clinical practice recommendations for thumb CMC arthritis and de Quervain’s.
- ACR Appropriateness Criteria®. Acute hand and wrist trauma; infection red flags.
- Derry S, et al. Topical NSAIDs for hand and wrist pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
- NICE / Primary care guidance. Hand and wrist pain assessment: red flags, when to refer.