Introduction
Chronic anal fissures can cause debilitating pain and frustration. When conservative treatments like dietary changes, sitz baths, or topical creams fail, surgery becomes the next step. But between fissurectomy and sphincterotomy, which procedure offers better results, faster healing, and lower recurrence? This article breaks it down clinically and practically, helping patients and providers make informed decisions.
Understanding Anal Fissures and Chronicity
An anal fissure is a small tear in the lining of the anal canal. While acute fissures often heal on their own, chronic fissures—lasting more than six weeks—typically involve a cycle of pain, spasms of the internal anal sphincter, and impaired blood flow, preventing healing. Surgery is often required when this cycle can’t be broken with conservative care.
What Is a Fissurectomy?
A fissurectomy involves surgically excising the fissure and surrounding fibrotic tissue to promote healing. It may be done alone or alongside other procedures such as a sphincterotomy.
Pros:
- Simple, tissue-removal based approach
- Preserves sphincter muscle if done alone
- Can be combined with Botox injection
Cons:
- Slower healing time if done alone
- May not relieve sphincter spasm, a key cause of non-healing
- Higher chance of recurrence if sphincter hypertonia is not addressed
What Is a Sphincterotomy?
A lateral internal sphincterotomy involves a controlled division of a portion of the internal anal sphincter to relieve spasm, improve blood flow, and promote healing.
Pros:
- Directly addresses the primary cause: sphincter spasm
- Healing rates up to 95%
- Quick pain relief and faster healing than fissurectomy alone
Cons:
- Small risk (1–8%) of minor incontinence, especially in older patients or those with previous anorectal surgeries
- May not be ideal for patients with weak sphincter tone
Success Rates – What Does the Evidence Say?
Several studies support sphincterotomy as more effective for isolated chronic anal fissures:
| Procedure | Success Rate | Recurrence | Incontinence Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sphincterotomy | 90–95% | <10% | 1–8% (minor, mostly gas) |
| Fissurectomy Alone | 60–75% | 20–30% | Very low |
| Fissurectomy + Sphincterotomy | 90–95% | <10% | 1–8% |
Which Surgery Heals Faster?
- Sphincterotomy generally leads to faster pain relief—within a few days—and complete healing in 4–6 weeks.
- Fissurectomy (without sphincterotomy) may take up to 8–10 weeks and carries a higher risk of delayed healing or wound breakdown.
Who Should Avoid Sphincterotomy?
Patients at higher risk of post-operative incontinence include:
- Older adults with reduced sphincter tone
- Women with prior childbirth trauma or perineal surgery
- Those with multiple previous anorectal surgeries
In such cases, Botox injection + fissurectomy may be a safer, though sometimes less effective, alternative.
When Is a Combined Approach Used?
In cases with:
- Chronic fissure with sentinel pile
- Fibrotic base and hypertrophied papilla
- Associated skin tags or anal stenosis
A combined fissurectomy and sphincterotomy provides the best outcomes—removing unhealthy tissue while resolving the sphincter spasm.
Postoperative Recovery Tips
Whether undergoing fissurectomy, sphincterotomy, or both, follow these recovery tips:
- Sitz baths 2–3 times daily
- Stool softeners (e.g., lactulose or PEG)
- High-fiber diet
- Pain management with NSAIDs or acetaminophen
- Avoid constipation or straining at all costs
Final Verdict – Which One Is Better?
| Situation | Preferred Surgery |
|---|---|
| Chronic fissure with sphincter spasm | Sphincterotomy |
| Chronic fissure without spasm or high risk of incontinence | Fissurectomy |
| Complex or recurrent fissure | Fissurectomy + Sphincterotomy |
| High-risk patients (e.g., elderly, prior surgery) | Botox or Fissurectomy Alone |
FAQs on Anal Fissure Surgery
Q1: Can fissures come back after sphincterotomy?
Yes, but the recurrence rate is low—under 10%. Lifestyle changes help prevent relapse.
Q2: Is sphincterotomy painful?
Pain usually reduces significantly within a few days post-op. It’s often less painful than untreated fissures.
Q3: How long is the downtime after surgery?
Most patients resume normal activities within 7–10 days, but complete healing may take 4–6 weeks.
Q4: Will I need anesthesia?
Yes. Both procedures are usually done under spinal or general anesthesia.
Conclusion
For most cases of chronic anal fissure, sphincterotomy remains the gold standard—offering faster healing and fewer recurrences. However, individual patient factors such as age, prior surgeries, and sphincter tone must guide the decision. When in doubt, a combined or conservative surgical approach may be safer.
Always consult a colorectal surgeon with experience in both techniques to tailor the best approach for your case.
Also Read:
