Preexisting Condition

Injured driver may have back pain secondary to muscle spasm needing conservative treatment prior to auto accident. Pain is a symptom. Injured driver had symptom of pain in lower back secondary to back muscle spasm. Patient may have been treated with medication, physical therapy or trigger point injection. Following auto accident, driver may continue with back pain of increased intensity and change of character of pain. Change in character of pain is presented by patient’s history which is subjective. Pain was dull intermittent prior to accident and after accident it is continuous and stabbing. MRI and CAT scan of patient with back pain may show disk bulge or herniation with facet joint hypertrophy. Patient may or may not have gone through any investigation prior to accident. Now after auto accident, cause of pain is not just a spasm of back muscle anymore, it is either disk herniation causing radicular pain because of pinch nerve or pain caused by facet joint hypertrophy. But, insurance companies will use symptom such as back pain which was presented prior to auto accident as a pre-existing condition.

Patient will be advised by adjuster of insurance company to go through Independent Medical Evaluation (IME).   Independent Medical Evaluation physician after examination will conclude back pain was pre-existing condition. IME physician often ignores differential diagnosis of back pain before and after auto accident. In this case back pain is not pre-existing since prior to accident, pre-existing muscle spasm was causing back pain and after accident back pain was caused by disk herniation or facet joint injury.

Car Accident- Pre-existing Condition Dispute Claim by Insurance Companies

Some pre-existing conditions like disk herniation are well documented and investigated prior to accident. After accident there may not be any change seen in MRI, but patient may insist his pain has increased in intensity and duration. In this case diagnosis of pre-existing condition is not back pain but disk herniation. Since MRI does not show any changes in disk herniation, insurance companies may dispute the claim of disk herniation causing back pain following auto accident.

In short, pre-existing conditions are often disputed. Legal hassle at times postpones the required treatment. Delaying treatment may further deteriorate condition and prognosis is not favorable.

Written, Edited or Reviewed By:


Last Modified On: May 12, 2017

Pain Assist Inc.

Pramod Kerkar
  Note: Information provided is not a substitute for physician, hospital or any form of medical care. Examination and Investigation is necessary for correct diagnosis.

Popular Video

Human Reproductive System & Childbirth

Symptom Checker

Hair Care

Irritable Bowel Syndrome

Weight Loss

Acne Health

Slideshow:  Home Remedies, Exercises, Diet and Nutrition

Find Pain Physician

Subscribe to Free ePainAssist Newsletters

By clicking Submit, I agree to the ePainAssist Terms & Conditions & Privacy Policy and understand that I may opt out of ePainAssist subscriptions at any time.

Copyright © 2018 ePainAssist, All rights reserved. Protection Status