Stress Fracture but X-ray is Normal: When Magnetic Resonance Imaging Matters and What to Do While Waiting

You did the “right” thing: you got an X-ray. The report comes back normal. But your pain is not normal—especially if it flares with walking, running, or hopping, and eases with rest. This is one of the most common (and most confusing) moments in sports medicine and orthopedics: a suspected stress fracture with a normal X-ray.

Here’s the key point up front: a normal X-ray does not rule out a stress fracture, particularly in the first days to weeks of symptoms. Stress fractures can be “invisible” on plain radiographs early on, and that is exactly where magnetic resonance imaging can change the whole game—by detecting bone stress injury sooner, clarifying severity, and helping prevent a small crack from becoming a bigger problem.

This guide explains:

• Why X-rays are often normal early
• When magnetic resonance imaging truly matters (and when it is urgent)
• What to do while waiting so you do not accidentally worsen the injury
• How recovery and return to activity usually works
• How to reduce the risk of recurrence

A stress fracture is a tiny crack in bone caused by repetitive load—often from running, jumping, marching, or a sudden increase in training volume or intensity. It can also occur when bone is weaker than it should be due to low bone density, nutrition issues, or medical conditions (sometimes called an insufficiency fracture).

Many clinicians now think in terms of a spectrum:

• Bone stress reaction (early stage; bone is irritated and inflamed but may not have a clear crack)
• Stress fracture (a more advanced stage with a detectable fracture line)

The earlier you catch it, the easier it often is to heal with activity modification and protection.

Plain X-rays are great for many fractures, but stress fractures can be subtle. Early on, the bone changes are microscopic. You may have significant pain even before the bone lays down healing material that becomes visible on X-ray.

Often the first thing an X-ray shows is not the fracture itself, but signs of healing (like callus formation). Mayo Clinic notes that stress fractures often cannot be seen on X-rays taken shortly after pain begins, and that it can take weeks before changes appear.

Clinical guidance commonly recommends initial radiography and, if negative but suspicion remains, repeating radiographs after a short interval (often about 2–3 weeks) to look for evolving changes.

The American College of Radiology also includes repeat radiography in 10–14 days as one possible next step in certain scenarios, but it also highlights situations where advanced imaging is appropriate.

Bottom line: Early normal X-ray is common. If symptoms and exam still fit a stress fracture, further evaluation is often warranted.

Magnetic resonance imaging is widely considered the best test for detecting stress fractures early because it can visualize bone marrow edema (early bone stress) and can often identify the fracture line and severity.

• Detects early bone stress injury before a crack is obvious
• Helps grade severity, which can guide how strict you need to be with offloading
• Can identify alternative diagnoses that mimic stress fracture pain (tendon injury, ligament injury, joint cartilage injury, bursitis, osteonecrosis, etc.)

The American College of Radiology’s Appropriateness Criteria for suspected stress fracture (excluding vertebrae) lists magnetic resonance imaging of the area of interest without intravenous contrast as “usually appropriate” when radiographs are negative or indeterminate.

Some stress fractures are labeled high-risk because they are more likely to progress, heal slowly, or develop nonunion. Classic high-risk locations include:

• Femoral neck (especially tension-side)
• Anterior tibial cortex
• Tarsal navicular (midfoot)
• Talus
• Medial malleolus
• Proximal fifth metatarsal (outside of foot)
• Sesamoids (under the big toe)

• Hip or groin pain with weight-bearing (concern for femoral neck stress fracture)
• Midfoot pain that feels deep and focal (navicular stress fractures can be easy to miss early)
• Pain that is worsening rapidly, pain at rest, or pain at night
• Inability to bear weight without significant limping
• A history of osteoporosis, prolonged steroid use, or other major bone-health risk factors (stress fractures are not only a runner’s issue).

High-risk stress fractures can require stricter immobilization, non-weight-bearing, or sometimes surgical consultation—so confirming the diagnosis matters.

While every case differs, many people describe a pattern like this:

• Pain begins gradually after an increase in activity (new running plan, more walking, harder surface)
• Pain is activity-related at first, then becomes easier to trigger
• Pain becomes more focal (you can point to one spot)
• Hopping on the affected limb may be painful (many clinicians use a hop test cautiously depending on location)

AAOS notes that if the injury is early, X-ray may look normal, and clinicians may treat based on exam and response.

Depending on your location, insurance, and access, magnetic resonance imaging may take time. Alternatives exist, but each has tradeoffs.

Repeat X-ray (radiography)

• May show changes after 10–21 days, especially healing response.
• Not ideal if the suspected site is high-risk and waiting could be costly.

Bone scan (nuclear medicine)

• Can be sensitive for increased bone turnover, but is generally less specific than magnetic resonance imaging for exact location and characterization.
• Involves radiation exposure.

Computed tomography scan

• Can show bony detail and may help when magnetic resonance imaging is unclear, but may miss early marrow edema and still uses radiation.

Many modern pathways favor magnetic resonance imaging when suspicion remains high after normal radiographs, consistent with ACR guidance.

If your clinician suspects a stress fracture, the safest approach while awaiting definitive imaging is to act as if it is a stress fracture—because continuing impact activity is one of the main reasons a small bone injury becomes a bigger one.

• Stop running, jumping, sports drills, and long fast walks.
• Avoid “testing it” daily. A stress fracture often feels slightly better with a couple days of rest, then flares again when you load it.

If you are limping or pain rises sharply with each step:

• Use crutches temporarily
• Consider a walking boot if recommended for foot/ankle/shin injuries
• Choose elevators, park closer, shorten errands

High-risk sites (hip/groin, midfoot navicular, anterior tibia, outside-of-foot fifth metatarsal area) deserve extra caution.

A helpful rule while waiting: If it hurts to walk normally, you are doing too much. Pain is not “weakness leaving the body” here—it can be the bone signaling that microscopic damage is still accumulating.

You can often maintain fitness with low-impact options, as long as they do not reproduce pain:

• Swimming
• Deep-water running
• Cycling with low resistance (if pain-free)
• Upper-body and core training

If cycling reproduces pain in a tibia, foot, or hip injury, stop and discuss other options.

• Many clinicians prefer acetaminophen for pain control in suspected fractures because it does not reduce inflammation.
• The question of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and bone healing is debated: some human evidence is inconsistent, but there is enough concern in the broader literature that many clinicians advise avoiding regular or prolonged use during fracture healing unless necessary.

If you need medication, discuss it with your clinician—especially if you have kidney disease, stomach ulcer history, or are on blood thinners.

Deep stretching, aggressive massage, and hard foam rolling directly over focal bone pain can irritate surrounding tissue and may encourage you to keep loading the area. Gentle mobility is fine, but avoid forcing pain.

Those features are not typical for a straightforward stress fracture and may suggest another diagnosis that needs evaluation.

A normal X-ray plus persistent, focal pain often leads to one of three paths:

Path 1: Treat empirically and reassess

 AAOS notes a clinician may begin treatment based on exam and see how you respond.

This is common when the suspected site is lower-risk and the patient can comfortably reduce loading.

Path 2: Order magnetic resonance imaging to confirm and grade.

Often chosen when:

• Pain persists despite rest;
• The athlete needs a confident diagnosis for return-to-play planning
• The suspected site carries higher risk
• The clinician is weighing different diagnoses (tendon vs bone vs joint)

Path 3: Escalate urgently for high-risk sites

High-risk locations and concerning symptoms warrant faster confirmation and stricter protection.

There is no single universal timeline because recovery depends on:

• Location (high-risk vs low-risk)
• Severity (stress reaction vs visible fracture line)
• How quickly loading is reduced
• Nutrition, sleep, bone health, and underlying risk factors

In general:

• Milder bone stress injuries may settle with several weeks of reduced impact.
• More advanced stress fractures can require 6–12 weeks or longer, especially in high-risk locations.

Mayo Clinic describes treatment that often includes rest, activity modification, and sometimes protective footwear or crutches depending on severity and location.

Stress fractures are often a “load vs capacity” problem: bone is asked to handle more than it can remodel.

• Sudden jump in mileage, speed work, hills, or hard-surface training
• Inadequate rest days
• Worn shoes or abrupt shoe changes
• Biomechanics issues (some people benefit from gait assessment and strength work)

• Low vitamin D or low calcium intake
• Low energy intake relative to training
• Menstrual cycle disruption in women athletes
• Low testosterone or other hormonal issues in men
• Osteoporosis or osteopenia
• Smoking, heavy alcohol use

AAOS highlights Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport as a condition where inadequate energy intake relative to training can impair health and performance, including bone health.

Research literature also links low energy availability and hormonal disruption with increased risk for bone stress injuries.

If stress fractures recur, or if the fracture occurred with relatively low activity, clinicians often consider laboratory evaluation and sometimes bone density testing.

The most common error is returning to impact activity based on calendar time rather than symptoms and function.

A safer progression usually includes:

1. Pain-free walking with a normal gait
2. Gradual increase in daily steps without pain flare
3. Low-impact conditioning tolerated
4. Stepwise return to run (walk-run intervals), increasing volume before intensity
5. No pain during activity and no pain the next morning

If pain returns, step back a phase. This is especially important for high-risk sites.

If walking is pain-free and you are not limping, many clinicians allow limited walking, but avoid long distances and fast pace. If you are limping or pain climbs with each step, reduce weight-bearing and consider crutches until evaluated.

If a clinician suspects a stress fracture, running is a common way to worsen it. A normal X-ray early does not make running safe.

Magnetic resonance imaging is highly effective for early detection and is often considered the best test for stress fractures, but no test is perfect. It is also useful because it can reveal alternative causes of pain.

It depends on location and severity. For high-risk sites (hip/groin, navicular midfoot, anterior tibia, proximal fifth metatarsal), it can be riskier to wait if you keep loading the limb—so the priority is protection and reduced loading while awaiting imaging.

If your pain pattern fits a stress fracture, a normal X-ray does not end the story. Early bone stress injuries can hide on radiographs for weeks. Magnetic resonance imaging matters because it can confirm the diagnosis sooner, grade severity, identify high-risk injuries, and guide the right level of protection.

While waiting:

• Stop impact
• Reduce weight-bearing if walking hurts
• Protect high-risk locations aggressively
• Use pain as a guardrail
• Address bone health, energy intake, and training errors

If you want, tell me where the pain is (for example: shin, top of foot, outside of foot, heel, hip/groin) and what activity triggered it, and I’ll add a location-specific “what to do while waiting” plan and the red flags unique to that bone (still with no tables).

References: