Homeopathy and naturopathy are the two commonly confused healthcare modalities but they are different practices based on different principles. These are two alternative medicine systems that are practiced globally today to search the root cause of an illness and to treat the patients at basic level. Both these systems follow a holistic approach to the treat the patients in holistic way rather treating the ailment or the specific disease. It is important to know the different between the two so that you can make informed decisions as regard your healthcare treatment options. So here is a comparison of homeopathy vs naturopathy for a better understanding.
The practices in naturopathy are aided by the clinical studies, while the field of homeopathy is based on the proving done on the medicines and its combinations. Both the homeopaths and naturopaths are licensed medical professionals and are authorized to diagnose and treat patients. Below is the comparison of homeopathy vs. naturopathy to give you a deep insight of both these fields and its treatment procedures.
Homeopathy vs. Naturopathy: Differences Worth Knowing
Homeopathy is comparatively the recently devised practice in medical system that came into existence in the 19th century. The basic principle of this medical practice is the "Like Treats Like" theory of treatment. According to practitioners of homeopathic medicine, extremely smaller doses of various substances (some also include toxins) can effectively cure the symptoms that larger dose typically causes. This field of medical science makes use of diluted medicines and it comprises of very little authentic substances. Homeopaths strongly believe that the diluted medicines used within this field are more effective as they are chemically identical to placebos and contain the spirit and fingerprint of the compounds. As homeopathic medicines are considered safe and do not have side effects, they have gained popularity in the treatment of chronic illnesses, when the conventional medicine does not have much to offer.
Naturopathy is a diversified and broad medical treatment system that includes a broad spectrum of practices. The naturopaths in the field follow a unique method of treatment that comprises acupressure, acupuncture, counseling, exercises, herbalism, specialized diets, Ayurvedic medicines, color therapy and other medical interventions that are drug-free. The primary aim of this field is to offer patients, a holistic treatment and complete care, while dealing with their emotional, spiritual and metaphysical aspects of health. Since it is more holistic and sustainable approach, many people prefer using naturopathy treatment instead of conventional medicine.
Homeopathy vs. Naturopathy – Differences Based on Diagnostic Methods
Both the fields specialize in treating chronic ailments. But there is a great difference in the diagnostic methods of homeopathy and naturopathy. Homeopaths usually perform extensive case taking that includes detailed health condition and health history of the patients. The questions asked during the case taking session are quite open-ended and are focused on encouraging the patients to describe their health better and express their experience in detail. Homeopaths evaluate the responses of the patients, keeping in mind the clinical symptoms and find suitable and effective remedy to treat the patient in holistic manner.
However, in naturopathy the diagnosis is performed by the naturopaths with a thorough medical history and physical examination of the patients. The treatments are planned and offered based on the reports of the tests and information gathered through the evaluation.
Homeopathy vs. Naturopathy - Differences Based on Benefits and Risks
Homeopathy is a popularly practiced domain in medical science today, owing to its little-to-no risk involved in it. Since most of the Homeopathic medicines don't comprise any chemical compounds, there is no risk of experiencing any unintended consequences. Clinical trials are still going and while many clinical cases show great results, scientific studies are yet to show the real benefits in treatment with homeopathy apart from the placebo effects.
On the other hand, naturopathy is also popularly practiced because its treatments are effective against a variety of diseases, but there are few risks involved and may be associated with medical interactions. The herbal extracts used for the treatment may cause life threatening allergic reaction in patients or may interact with other effective medical drugs. Also, some treatment modalities in naturopathy may not be well tolerated by some people and may result in side effects like skin irritation, digestive troubles, etc.
Homeopathy vs. Naturopathy – Differences Based on Treatment
The treatment offered in homeopathy is totally different from that offered in naturopathy.
Homeopathy typically offers remedies which are ultra-dilute dose of plant, minerals and other compounds that are derived from nature. After completing a course of remedy, homeopaths ask the patients for a follow-up visit to check the progress and make changes in the remedies for better outcomes.
Naturopathy treats patients with lifestyle counseling, exercise prescription, nutrition, hydrotherapy, physical medicine, botanical medicines and more. After prescribing the effective modality, the doctor may ask for a follow-up visit to track the progress of the ailment and make necessary changes to treat the condition completely.
Homeopathy vs. Naturopathy – Differences Based on Risks and Issues
Homeopathy and naturopathy, both have their own advantages and ways of treatment. Both the practices can be used to treat mild to moderate health conditions and infections effectively and safely. However, there may be limitations when it comes to serious ailments, surgery and emergency treatment.
As both these practices focus on the patient and provide a holistic approach, it depends a lot on the practitioner. While there are no side effects in homeopathy, any risk of selection of remedy and doses can be avoided by seeking treatment from a trained and certified homeopath. Similarly, as naturopathy poses certain health risks and reactions, it is important to take appropriate treatment from a qualified professional and with medical advice, if necessary. Pregnant and lactating women should seek medical advice before taking these treatments.
While much is discussed regarding homeopathy vs naturopathy, all doctors will agree to the fact that traditional medicines are sometimes the ultimate treatment for specific ailments than any alternative medicine. Patients suffering from long term or serious medical conditions may opt for medical interventions rather than alternative medicines, to treat the condition faster and to prevent complications.
So, now you have understood the principles, scientific background and treatment options used in both these systems. Homeopathy vs naturopath, as both have their advantages and limitations depending on your health condition, you can choose your treatment option.